Glasgow’s council hits back at claims its childcare pay rises will damage private sector
The council claims rising applications for nursery jobs show higher salaries are attracting workers, as private providers warn they cannot compete with public sector pay
Glasgow City Council has hit back at criticism it is paying its nursery staff too much in the latest row over pay and grading changes.
The local authority has faced criticism from private childcare providers who say they cannot compete with new pay rates and could lose qualified staff to the public sector.
A Glasgow council insider pointed to a surge in applications for nursery jobs as evidence that better wages are making the profession more attractive.
They said: “It’s difficult to understand why we are being criticised for paying people too much - the increase in the number of applications to our recent job adverts is evidence that people are attracted to the job and the new pay and grading.
“That can only be a positive for both the successful applicant and our children.”
The row comes as Glasgow prepares to introduce a new pay and grading structure in April 2027, under which Child Development Officers (CDOs) will earn between £36,737 and £45,023.
Their existing salary scale ranges from £32,025 to £36,152.
The council says the increases reflect the work CDOs play in children's education, emotional development and preparation for school.
However, the new minimum pay rate for nursery practitioners in council settings equates to nearly 50 per cent more than in the PVI sector (private, voluntary and independent nurseries).
A campaign group of PVI providers told The Scotsman earlier this year they would have to increase fees by as much as £25 per child per day to stop an “exodus” to the public sector.
Christine and Joanna, two CDOs working in the south side of Glasgow, see the fight for fair recognition of the work they do as being part of a 20-year campaign.
In 2004, CDOs, then known as nursery nurses, went on strike for 14 weeks in a dispute over pay, working conditions and the failure to recognise the demands of their jobs.
Christine said: “We were working against low pay, the increased responsibilities, the lack of recognition, and the strike was about much more than money.”
Both women regard the struggle for recognition as a campaign spanning more than 20 years.
They say the work is routinely mischaracterised as childcare, overlooking the role CDOs play in shaping children's development during their earliest and most formative years.
Christine said: “We play such a fundamental part in the children's education, emotional wellbeing, social development, and preparation for school.
“A CDO can be one of the key professionals in a child's early education.
“The first five years of a child's life are so important, where they develop the foundations for speech and language, communication, emotional development, self-regulation, social skills and friendships, physical development and coordination, confidence, independence, and resilience, early literacy and numeracy.”
They are not, Joanna added, “simply providing childcare while parents go to work but helping shape children's futures at one of the most influential stages of their life”.
The area of the city where the women have both worked - Christine for 34 years and Joanna for 13 - has high levels of deprivation.
Joanna believes their work helps narrow the poverty-related attainment gap both by working with the children and also closely with families.
She also points out that CDOs use the same working documents as teachers for the early level curriculum.
Further, they recommend children for additional supports such as speech and language or psychology and then work with the children on those early interventions, particularly as the number of children with additional support needs rises.
Christine said: “And for any children who go into care, we are usually the most consistent adult in their life, especially when they move from carer to carer.”
When the profession walked out on strike in Glasgow, Christine said this was because the predominantly female workforce was being undervalued.
Of all the local authorities faced with industrial action at the time, the Glasgow workers stayed out the longest.
The council's defence of its pay settlement is also based on a wider attempt to address what it describes as discriminatory elements of its existing pay system.
An analysis of more than 19,000 employees in roles evaluated so far found that 16,362, or 84.6 per cent, would receive a pay increase under the new structure, while 832 would see no change. Overall, 88.8 per cent would experience either a positive or neutral outcome.
More than 4,000 employees - 22 per cent - would receive increases of more than 20 per cent, while 42 per cent would gain more than 10 per cent.
However, 2,158 employees, or 11.2 per cent, would experience some degree of financial detriment. The council said 58 per cent of those affected would see a reduction of 3 per cent or less, while 87 per cent would face a reduction of no more than 10 per cent.
Only 284 employees are expected to experience detriment of more than 10 per cent, including 42 who would lose more than 20 per cent.
A spokesman said: “Glasgow City Council’s current pay and grading scheme is discriminatory – it does not always reward equal work with equal pay.
“We need to replace it with a new scheme and we have agreed to do so in April 2027.
“When we do, more than 85 per cent of our employees whose posts have been evaluated will see their pay increase.
“Although a minority of around 11 per cent will face a loss, we recognise the impact that will have and have committed to protecting their pay until April 2030.”
The authority has also pointed to the response to its latest recruitment campaign as evidence that the new rates are attracting applicants.
A recent advert for permanent CDO positions across Glasgow received 593 applications, including 252 from external candidates and 341 from existing council employees.
Comments
Want to join the conversation? Please or to comment on this article.
